Skip to Content
  • facebook
  • X
  • instagram
  • youtube
  • flickr
  • WAGNER.EDU
  • A-Z
    A
    • Academic Advising & Accessibility
    • Academic and Cultural Enrichment
    • Admissions
    • Alumni & Friends
    • Anthropology Department
    • Arts Administration
    • Athletics
    B
    • Biological Sciences Department
    • Bookstore
    • Business, Nicolais School
    • Business Office
    C
    • Calendar
    • Campus Life
    • Campus Safety
    • Campus Services
    • Career Planning & Development
    • Center for Intercultural Advancement
    • Center for Leadership & Community Engagement
    • Center for Spirituality
    • Children & Teens Programs
    • Commencement
    • Communications & Marketing
    • Conference Services
    • Continuing Education
    D
    • Dance Program
    • Dining Services
    E
    • Early Childhood Center
    • Education Department
    • English Department
    • Expanding Your Horizons
    F
    • Film & Media
    • Film & Photo Shoots
    • Financial Aid
    G
    • Gender Studies
    • Government & Politics Department
    • Give to Wagner
    H
    • HawkTalk Blog
    • Health & Wellness
    • History Department
    • Holocaust Center
    • Honors Program
    • Human Resources
    I
    • Information Technology
    • Institutional Advancement
    L
    • Library
    • Lifelong Learning Department
    M
    • Math & Computer Science
    • Modern Languages, Literatures & Cultures
    • Music Department
    N
    • Newsroom
    • New Students Hub
    • Nursing, Evelyn L. Spiro School
    P
    • Performing Arts
    • Philosophy & Religious Studies Department
    • Physical Sciences Department
    • Physician Assistant
    • Planetarium
    • Pre-Health Science Program
    • Pre-Law Program
    • President’s Office
    • Provost’s Office
    • Psychology Department
    R
    • Registrar
    • Residential Education
    S
    • Sociology Department
    • Student Engagement and Activities
    • Student Government Association
    • Study Abroad
    T
    • Theatre
    • Theatre Season
    • Title IX
    V
    • Veteran’s Resources
    • Visual Arts Department
    W
    • Wagner Fund
    • Wagner Magazine
    • WCBG Student Radio
    • Writing Center
  • QuickLinks
    ONLINE
    • Directory
    • Follett Discover Access
    • Handshake
    • Mailport
    • Moodle
    • myWagner
    • OneLogin
    ON CAMPUS
    • Events Calendar
    • Job Opportunities
    • Library
    • Registrar’s Office
    • Theatre Season
    • Visit Us
    • Webcam
    MORE RESOURCES
    • For Employees
    • For Faculty
    • For Current Students
    • For New Students
    • For Community
    • For Alumni
    • For Parents
Wagner College Newsroom
  • Wagner In the News
  • Events
  • Contact
  • Newsroom MENU
    • WAGNER.EDU
    - Prev Article Essay reflects on poisoned water in Flint, Mich., and how we teach - Next Article
    February 2, 2016 Share
    Share on facebook
    Facebook
    Share on twitter
    Twitter
    Share on google
    Google
    Share on linkedin
    Linkedin
    Share on pinterest
    Pinterest
    Share on email
    Email
    Text Size

    Alexa DietrichWagner College anthropology professor Alexa Dietrich, author of an award-winning study of corporate pollution in Puerto Rico, reflects on how we teach students to critically assess issues associated with environmental crisis and justice.

    When events that are understood to be tragic happen, like the poisoning of the residents of Flint, Michigan, it is typical for us, as human beings, to ask, “Why?” When these events affect whole communities, it then becomes incumbent upon us, as human beings, to ask, “How could this happen?” — because the cause is far less likely to be a random occurrence. Students tend to sense this connection intrinsically, but struggle to think critically about causal factors in situations like Flint.

    In classroom discussions, students will often respond to stories of severe environmental pollution in one of two ways.

    Sometimes they express bewilderment. They feel the inherent injustice, but cannot fathom a reason for the damage to people’s health and well-being.

    The other common response — voiced by one of my students this week in talking about the toxic waste in Flint’s drinking water — is to say, “It’s almost as if someone planned it.”

    It is easy to see conspiracy behind a series of what were, with the benefit of hindsight, a series of despicable acts leading to the potential devastation of an entire community, particularly a community already so disadvantaged and seemingly disposable as Flint. To our shame, in the United States we have long since become terribly inured to the suffering of communities of color and poor communities.

    But while it is easy to imagine a conspiracy of evilly inclined individuals, such as politicians, plotting to wipe out a community like Flint, this perspective avoids the hard conversations we need to have with our students and others. Explicitly evil intentions are not required in order for great harm to be perpetrated. I am not suggesting that politicians, such as Rick Snyder, are “innocent” in this situation — far from it. Rather, we need to be having frank discussions, leading to actions, about how our culture rewards greed at the expense of human life — especially the lives of the poor and oppressed minorities.

    We must, as educators and students, together answer the question, “How could this happen?” The fact is that people with the power to protect the lives of Flint residents chose not to do so. Not once, but many times, people in a position to make decisions about sourcing the water, about testing the water, about reporting the test results and health impacts, made decisions for financial gain or political expedience. And our cultural system (encompassing, for example, economics, social relations and ideologies) reinforced the permissibility, the very social and political acceptability of those decisions. There were undoubtedly both legal and moral crimes committed — but accountability for these crimes should weigh heavily on all of us.

    In the aftermath of a public health crisis like that in Flint, there are likely to be emerging narratives of the heroic actions of empowered individuals, those who seem to swoop in as community saviors. However, a culture of community engagement cannot, and will not, wait for such heroes, as significant as their contributions may be. As one Flint resident and activist has been quoted as saying, “I decided, I guess I got to figure the science part of this, because you can’t argue with the science.” In the pursuit of environmental justice, there is no substitute for the actions of “non-experts” with local knowledge and local commitment. But it is also our responsibility to teach and reward this commitment to collective good on a broad scale, more than we currently reward (or at least accept) harmful self-interest and the violence of disinterest in the well-being of others.

    It is also tempting to rely on the explanation of “bad apples,” or individual actors, as is so often used to describe the causes of violence and social suffering perpetrated by institutions. But these explanations are too simple, and release us from our own obligations to care for our fellow human beings. How could this happen? The answer lies in a larger examination of our culture, and our individual roles in it.

    Alexa S. Dietrich teaches anthropology at Wagner College, where she is also the faculty director of Wagner’s First-Year Learning Communities. Her book, “The Drug Company Next Door” (NYU Press, 2013), won the 2015 Julian Steward Award for the best monograph in environmental and ecological anthropology from the American Anthropological Association.

    This essay was first published by NYU Press on Feb. 1 on its “From the Square” blog. It is reprinted here by permission.

    IN THIS STORY

     

    Alexa Dietrich

    View Full Profile
     
     
      • Anthropology Department News
      • Homepage Feature
      • Wagner News

    Popular Stories

    • Main Hall architects rendering min Main Hall architects rendering min

      A century on Staten Island

      November 27, 2018

    • IMG 2514 1 IMG 2514 1

      From basement to bookshelf: Wagner’s long-lost library book resurfaces after 27 years

      February 22, 2025

    • Julian Bond Julian Bond

      Civil rights leader Julian Bond to speak at commencement, May 23

      May 18, 2014
     

    Related Stories

    rb resize 1Hidden Image June 27, 2025 Wagner Alum, Former Chairman Robert O’Brien Passes Away at 81 The Wagner College community is mourning a former trustees chairman who devoted much of his life to bettering his alma mater and his community.
    Wagner College stone sign1Hidden Image June 17, 2025 Higher Ed Authority Carnegie: Wagner Graduates Earn More The newly released 2025 Carnegie Classifications of Institutions of Higher Education has designated Wagner College a “higher earnings” school for alumni.
    annfrank artHidden Image June 13, 2025 Teens Create Artworks Inspired by Anne Frank Students from public and parochial schools across Staten Island were invited to submit works of visual and written art to the Wagner College Holocaust Center in honor of the “life, courage and spirit” of Anne Frank.
    career activator 1Hidden Image June 10, 2025 Career-Prep Program Blends Class, Employer Experiences Now preparing its fifth cohort of Wagner College students, the Career Activator Program has helped numerous students with professional career development over the years.
    Wagner College stone sign1Hidden Image June 2, 2025 Wagner Student Named 2025–2026 Newman Civic Fellow The prestigious yearlong fellowship recognizes student leaders who are committed to creating positive change in their communities.
    PT108146Hidden Image May 23, 2025 Spotlight on Student Success at Senior Awards Wagner College recognized the academic achievement, leadership, and service of its graduating seniors during the 2025 Senior Awards Ceremony.
    wagner graduation 8Hidden Image May 22, 2025 Wagner College Bids Farewell to the Class of 2025 Despite the rain, spirits and smiles were bright upon the hill last Thursday and Friday, where the commencement ceremonies for the Wagner College Class of 2025 proceeded with much enthusiasm.
    IMG 3396 1 scaled e1747837528133Hidden Image May 21, 2025 In Perfect Harmony: A Life in Lessons and Lyrics Skill builds some careers, while passion builds others. For Wagner College alum Charles Poveromo, more commonly known by his stage name of Charlie Romo, he’s blessed with both.  
    wfc24 1502Hidden Image May 15, 2025 Undergraduate Commencement To Be Held Outdoors as Planned The Wagner College Undergraduate Commencement Ceremony scheduled for tomorrow will be held outdoors as planned.
     
    • Wagner Magazine

      Stories from alumni around the world.

      Read the magazine

    • Contact the newsroom

      communications@wagner.edu

    • Visit Campus
    • Explore Majors
    • Library
    • Make a Gift
    Wagner College
    Work One Campus Road
    Staten Island, NY 10301
    • CONTACT US
    • Privacy Policy
    Back top