Skip to Content
  • facebook
  • twitter
  • instagram
  • youtube
  • flickr
  • WAGNER.EDU
  • A-Z
    A
    • Academic and Cultural Enrichment
    • Admissions
    • Alumni & Friends
    • Anthropology Department
    • Arts Administration
    • Athletics
    B
    • Biological Sciences Department
    • Bookstore
    • Business, Nicolais School
    • Business Office
    C
    • Calendar
    • Campus Life
    • Campus Services
    • Center for Academic & Career Engagement
    • Center for Intercultural Advancement
    • Center for Leadership & Community Engagement
    • Center for Spirituality
    • Children & Teens Programs
    • Commencement
    • Communications & Marketing
    • Conference Services
    • Continuing Education
    D
    • Dance Program
    • Dining Services
    • Diversity, Equity and Inclusion
    E
    • Early Childhood Center
    • Economics Department
    • Education Department
    • English Department
    • Expanding Your Horizons
    F
    • Faculty Research Sites
    • Film & Media
    • Film & Photo Shoots
    • Financial Aid
    G
    • Gender Studies
    • Government & Politics Department
    • Give to Wagner
    H
    • HawkTalk Blog
    • Health & Wellness
    • History Department
    • Holocaust Center
    • Honors Program
    • Hugh L. Carey Institute for Government Reform
    • Human Resources
    I
    • Information Technology
    • Institutional Advancement
    L
    • Library
    • Lifelong Learning Department
    M
    • Math & Computer Science
    • Modern Languages, Literatures & Cultures
    • Music Department
    N
    • Newsroom
    • New Students Hub
    • Nursing, Evelyn L. Spiro School
    P
    • Performing Arts
    • Philosophy & Religious Studies Department
    • Physical Sciences Department
    • Physician Assistant
    • Planetarium
    • Pre-Health Science Program
    • Pre-Law Program
    • President’s Office
    • Provost’s Office
    • Psychology Department
    • Public Safety
    R
    • Registrar
    • Residential Education
    S
    • Sociology Department
    • Student Engagement and Activities
    • Student Government Association
    • Study Abroad
    T
    • Theatre
    • Theatre Season
    • Title IX
    V
    • Veteran’s Resources
    • Visual Arts Department
    W
    • Wagner Fund
    • Wagner Magazine
    • WCBG Student Radio
    • Writing Center
  • QuickLinks
    ONLINE
    • Directory
    • Follett Discover Access
    • Mailport
    • Make a Gift
    • Moodle
    • myWagner
    • Wagner Works
    ON CAMPUS
    • Events Calendar
    • Job Opportunities
    • Library
    • Registrar’s Office
    • Theatre Season
    • Visit Us
    • Webcam
    MORE RESOURCES
    • For Employees
    • For Faculty
    • For Current Students
    • For New Students
    • For Community
    • For Alumni
    • For Parents
Wagner College Newsroom
  • Events
  • Stories
  • Contact
  • Newsroom MENU
    • WAGNER.EDU
    On the departure of White House Chief of Staff Rahm Emmanuel
    November 2, 2010 Share
    Share on Facebook
    Facebook
    Tweet about this on Twitter
    Twitter
    Share on LinkedIn
    Linkedin
    Pin on Pinterest
    Pinterest
    Email this to someone
    email
    Text Size


    October 18, 2010
    RAHM AND THE ULTIMATE DEAD-END JOB
    By JOSHUA SPIVAK
        Perplexed by Rahm Emanuel’s decision to quit as White House chief of staff, arguably the second most powerful political position in the country, in order to run for mayor of Chicago?
        You’re not alone. Even Emanuel certainly hasn’t provided any real insight into why he is making the jump. If he’s hoping to further his political career beyond the Windy City, it is a strange decision. Recent history shows that a big city mayoralty is usually the end of the line.
        Over the last half century, few of the mayors of America’s largest cities have had a political career after being mayor. Only three managed to be elected either governor or senator — Phoenix’s Jack Williams, San Diego’s Peter Wilson, who served as both governor and senator, and Philly’s Ed Rendell.
        Three others managed to be appointed to a cabinet position — San Jose’s Norm Mineta, Dallas’s Ron Kirk and San Antonio’s Henry Cisneros. Two, Mineta and Dallas’ Earle Cabell, went to the House, and a few went to the state legislature or back to the city council, but for the vast majority it was the end of their public career.
        The top five cities — New York, L.A., Chicago, Houston and Phoenix — are almost a complete shut out in promoting a political career. Only Phoenix’s mayor, Jack Williams, was elected as Arizona’s governor in 1966. Phoenix does have one other noteworthy former mayor, Terry Goddard, now the current Arizona attorney general and the Democratic nominee for governor. But he, like the former mayor of Houston who is the gubernatorial nominee in Texas, is behind in the polls.
        In Chicago, the failure of advancement may be blamed on the stranglehold that the Daley’s have maintained on the mayoralty — the father and son have held the position for 43 of the last 55 years. Other cities have no such longevity problem. Being mayor of New York is a famous political death sentence. Rudy Giuliani’s failed presidential campaign served as a recent monument to the dead-end nature of the job.
        No New York mayor since 1869 has won higher office, and no elected mayor in the 20th century won another office of any kind. Mayors are also poorly represented in the presidency. Only two mayors have ever been elected president — Grover Cleveland of Buffalo and Calvin Coolidge of Northampton.
        One reason it may be so hard to advance after being a mayor is that they frequently receive a lot more press scrutiny than governors, despite the fact that they are overseeing cities that are a fraction of their state’s size. Newspapers and TV stations no longer make the state capital a priority, whereas City Hall is always scrutinized and covered.
        And there’s another big negative for mayors — they are begrudged by the rest of the state’s populace who don’t reside in the city. Former New York City Mayor Ed Koch is the prime example of this, though it was due to his own blunder. During his unsuccessful run for the governor’s mansion, he called the suburbs “sterile” and said “it’s wasting your life.” Unsurprisingly, this cost him the primary race.
        Emanuel might have stepped down from the chief of staff position regardless of the mayoral opening. Despite its power, chief of staffs frequently burn out or get pushed out after a few years in office. Since Nixon’s time, only two have lasted three or more years in the position.
        But Emanuel is a heavy political hitter who is not burned out on politics. And the mayor of Chicago is a powerful position. So it could be possible that Emanuel is looking at the job as a capstone to his career — he could turn Chicago into a 21st century city.
        Although it’s still tough to believe that Emanuel wants to step off the national stage at age 50. So it will be most interesting to see how he makes a comeback from what has been the ultimate dead-end political job.
        Joshua Spivak is a senior fellow at the Hugh L. Carey Institute for Government Reform at Wagner College.
     

      • Uncategorized

    Popular Stories

    • Harry Jackson1 Harry Jackson1

      Former SGA leader Harry Jackson ’09 dies

      August 3, 2022

    • Alumni Awards ProgramLR Alumni Awards ProgramLR

      2022 Alumni Awards

      July 14, 2022

    • Charles DArrigo Charles DArrigo

      Former trustee Charles D’Arrigo ’51 dies

      April 21, 2016
     

    Related Stories

    main hall building imageHidden Image May 23, 2022 Spring 2022 pinning ceremony On Thursday, May 19, Wagner College’s Evelyn L. Spiro School of Nursing held its spring pinning ceremony in the Main Hall auditorium for those graduating with a bachelor of science in nursing degree
    Spring BreakHidden Image March 16, 2022 Spring Break 2022 What’s open, and when, during Spring Break week, March 19-27
    WinterHidden Image January 13, 2022 Winter Break campus service hours What’s open — and when — throughout the 2021-22 Winter Break
    main hall building imageHidden Image November 17, 2021 Faculty awards 2021 Congratulations to all the Wagner College faculty members whose exceptional performance and career milestones were recognized at the annual Faculty Awards Dinner on Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2021. FACULTY AWARDS
    Tarshia Stanley1Hidden Image November 4, 2021 Wagner College’s next provost is Tarshia Stanley Currently a dean at St. Catherine University in Minnesota, Stanley will take office June 1
    Autumnal sceneaHidden Image October 8, 2021 Fall Break 2021 What’s open on campus, and when, over the Fall Break weekend, Oct. 9-12
    The cast singing togetherHidden Image September 15, 2021 Wagner College Theatre lineup ‘Small Mouth Sounds’ opens Stage One season Oct. 7; Main Stage season opens with ‘Into the Woods’ Oct. 21
    main hall building imageHidden Image May 10, 2021 Current exhibition: Orly Cogan ‘Go Your Own Way’ Wagner College Union Gallery is pleased to present this selection of work from the fiber and multi-media artist Orly Cogan. Through her tapestries,
    main hall building imageHidden Image March 10, 2021 2021 Black History Month Read-Aloud On Thursday, March 4, several members of the Wagner College community participated in the 2021 Black History Month Read-Aloud, reading brief selections from the poems, novels and essays of Black writers.
     
    • Wagner Magazine

      Stories from alumni around the world.

      Read the magazine

    • Contact the newsroom

      Media relations director Lee Manchester
      lee.manchester@wagner.edu
      718-420-4504

    • Wagner in the media

      Wagner College 2019 news coverage

      Browse Catalog

    • Visit Campus
    • Explore Majors
    • Library
    • Make a Gift
    Wagner College
    Work One Campus Road
    Staten Island, NY 10301
    • CONTACT US
    • Privacy Policy
    Back top