Skip to Content
  • facebook
  • twitter
  • instagram
  • youtube
  • flickr
  • WAGNER.EDU
  • A-Z
    A
    • Academic Advising & Accessibility
    • Academic and Cultural Enrichment
    • Admissions
    • Alumni & Friends
    • Anthropology Department
    • Arts Administration
    • Athletics
    B
    • Biological Sciences Department
    • Bookstore
    • Business, Nicolais School
    • Business Office
    C
    • Calendar
    • Campus Life
    • Campus Services
    • Career Planning & Development
    • Center for Intercultural Advancement
    • Center for Leadership & Community Engagement
    • Center for Spirituality
    • Children & Teens Programs
    • Commencement
    • Communications & Marketing
    • Conference Services
    • Continuing Education
    D
    • Dance Program
    • Dining Services
    • Diversity, Equity and Inclusion
    E
    • Early Childhood Center
    • Economics Department
    • Education Department
    • English Department
    • Expanding Your Horizons
    F
    • Film & Media
    • Film & Photo Shoots
    • Financial Aid
    G
    • Gender Studies
    • Government & Politics Department
    • Give to Wagner
    H
    • HawkTalk Blog
    • Health & Wellness
    • History Department
    • Holocaust Center
    • Honors Program
    • Hugh L. Carey Institute for Government Reform
    • Human Resources
    I
    • Information Technology
    • Institutional Advancement
    L
    • Library
    • Lifelong Learning Department
    M
    • Math & Computer Science
    • Modern Languages, Literatures & Cultures
    • Music Department
    N
    • Newsroom
    • New Students Hub
    • Nursing, Evelyn L. Spiro School
    P
    • Performing Arts
    • Philosophy & Religious Studies Department
    • Physical Sciences Department
    • Physician Assistant
    • Planetarium
    • Pre-Health Science Program
    • Pre-Law Program
    • President’s Office
    • Provost’s Office
    • Psychology Department
    • Public Safety
    R
    • Registrar
    • Residential Education
    S
    • Sociology Department
    • Student Engagement and Activities
    • Student Government Association
    • Study Abroad
    T
    • Theatre
    • Theatre Season
    • Title IX
    V
    • Veteran’s Resources
    • Visual Arts Department
    W
    • Wagner Fund
    • Wagner Magazine
    • WCBG Student Radio
    • Writing Center
  • QuickLinks
    ONLINE
    • Directory
    • Follett Discover Access
    • Handshake
    • Mailport
    • Moodle
    • myWagner
    • OneLogin
    ON CAMPUS
    • Events Calendar
    • Job Opportunities
    • Library
    • Registrar’s Office
    • Theatre Season
    • Visit Us
    • Webcam
    MORE RESOURCES
    • For Employees
    • For Faculty
    • For Current Students
    • For New Students
    • For Community
    • For Alumni
    • For Parents
Wagner College Newsroom
  • Events
  • Stories
  • Contact
  • Newsroom MENU
    • WAGNER.EDU
    For mayor, the odds aren’t great (Miami mayoral recall)
    December 15, 2010 Share
    Share on facebook
    Facebook
    Share on twitter
    Twitter
    Share on google
    Google
    Share on linkedin
    Linkedin
    Share on pinterest
    Pinterest
    Share on email
    Email
    Text Size


    Friday, Nov. 5, 2010
    RECALL: FOR MAYOR, THE ODDS AREN’T GREAT
    By JOSHUA SPIVAK
        Facing a well funded recall campaign, Mayor Carlos Alvarez has good reason to worry. In addition to the fact that he could be forced to face the voters at a time of serious voter anger at elected officials, the nature of the recall operates against its target. Once on the ballot, recalls have a good chance of succeeding.
        Most recalls fail, primarily because they never get anywhere near the ballot. Getting enough signatures to qualify for the ballot is an expensive and time-consuming process. Most jurisdictions also require a large number of signatures to qualify — usually around 20-25 percent of either eligible voters or the amount of votes cast for that position in the last election (a much lower number).
        The Miami-Dade mayoral recall seems to have easily surmounted those problems. Thanks to Norman Braman, proponents possessed ample funds to pay for signature gathering, legal fees and all the other expenses that usually doom a recall. And the signature requirement was very low, an estimated 52,000 valid signatures, or about 4 percent of registered voters.
        With the proponents saying they have 90,000 signatures in hand, it seems likely that the recall will be going to the voters. Once there, the recall has a very good chance of success. There has not been a full study on the recall, but it appears that among state-level officials, over half of recalls that get on the ballot result in the removal of the officials. Only two governors have faced a recall in the nation’s history, California’s Gray Davis in 2003 and North Dakota’s Lynn Frazier in 1921. Both were removed. There have been at least 20 state legislators who have faced a recall; 13 of those officials were tossed out.
        Part of the explanation for this success is the basic fact that a recall getting on the ballot usually means the elected official is running into a buzzsaw of voter anger against his or her policies or behavior. But that is not the most important reason. Recall votes are generally stand-alone special elections. Voters have to both be aware of the recall vote and care enough to come out to cast a ballot for one race. Unsurprisingly, voters who come out to cast their ballots are often the most highly motivated, which certainly defines people who are intent on removing an elected official.
        The average voter, who usually comes out to vote on a whole slate worth of candidates, is more likely to skip special elections. For example, in 1995, three California Assembly members faced recalls. Each of these well-publicized elections drew from 25 percent to 35 percent of registered voters, well below the turnout for a general election. There are counter-examples, most prominently the circus-like recall of Gray Davis, where turnout was higher than at his election, but generally the turnout is heavily depressed.
        When recalls take place on a nonspecial election basis, i.e. the same day as a regularly scheduled vote, candidates seem to fare better. The two most recent state legislative recalls, one in California, the other in Michigan, both of which took place in 2008, illustrate this point. Both were scheduled for the same day as a primary, and both candidates survived.
        Despite these grim facts, Alvarez does have cards to play.
        So far, the recall campaign is uniquely tied to one backer. Most recalls that succeed have garnered a broad base of support — recall proponents manage to make the campaign one of an incompetent, corrupt or uncaring official versus the voters.
        However, if the campaign is one elected official versus one rich opponent, the narrative may change in the mayor’s favor. Changing the narrative can help even in extreme cases. Recently, the mayor of Ridgefield, N.J., survived a recall, despite the fact that he was facing federal corruption charges. The fact that it was led by his Republican opponents could not have helped their campaign.
        For Mayor Alvarez, the odds are not great. Once on the ballot, voters are not afraid to toss out the target. The biggest hurdle to his removal may have already been surmounted.
        Joshua Spivak is a senior fellow at the Hugh L. Carey Institute for Government Reform at Wagner College in New York.

      • Uncategorized

    Popular Stories

    • MG 1129 1 Michelle Siemens MG 1129 1 Michelle Siemens

      Magic and mayhem: Wagner College Theatre opens the season October 5 with ‘Pippin’

      September 28, 2023

    • DSC00293 DSC00293

      ‘We need you desperately,’ NYC Schools Chancellor David C. Banks tells educators at Wagner College Teacher Resiliency Forum

      September 29, 2023

    • Jeffrey Forchelli e1695133310720 Jeffrey Forchelli e1695133310720

      Presidential Search Announcement from the Board Chair

      September 19, 2023
     

    Related Stories

    DSC00293Hidden Image September 29, 2023 ‘We need you desperately,’ NYC Schools Chancellor David C. Banks tells educators at Wagner College Teacher Resiliency Forum By Andrew Housman Delivering an impassioned keynote speech and earning a standing ovation at the Wagner College Teacher Resiliency Panel Forum on Thursday, New York City Schools Chancellor David C. Banks
    angelo 2022 commencement 1Hidden Image September 18, 2023 President Angelo Araimo to retire following 2023-24 academic year Wagner College President Angelo Araimo Longtime leader to conclude 30-year tenure, calls Wagner College “strong and poised to thrive” Angelo Araimo, president of Wagner College, announced his retirement
    Hidden Image September 16, 2023 Seahawk Spotlight: Preserving Wagner archives, a pilot dance program in Brooklyn, and more By Lindsey Schwarzbach Seahawk Spotlight is a monthly roundup covering campus happenings and student, faculty and staff accolades for Wagner College. Below are highlights from September 2023. Wagner
    DSC05268editHidden Image August 28, 2023 Wagner College students settle in as 2023-24 academic year begins By Max Dickstein Hundreds of Wagner College students made their way through campus on the first day of classes on Monday, among them 410 new students and 100 transfers. History professor Lori Weintrob
    Evelyn L Spiro School of Nursing Wagner CollegeHidden Image August 16, 2023 Evelyn L. Spiro School of Nursing at Wagner College announces ACEN site visit The Evelyn L. Spiro School of Nursing at Wagner College will host a site visit from September 12-14, 2023, by the Accreditation Commission on Education in Nursing (ACEN) for the initial accreditation
    IMG 2397Hidden Image August 8, 2023 ‘The other side of medicine’: Wagner PA students care for summer campers with serious diagnoses at Double H Ranch (courtesy Miriam Mikhail) By Andrew Housman Aimee Kaldas, Wagner College Physician Assistant Program student and Double H Ranch counselor-for-a-week, had just started a camp sing-along about drinking
    Hawkins Taviare RS 0135 1Hidden Image August 7, 2023 Taviare Hawkins appointed assistant provost for research, development and civic engagement Taviare Hawkins appointed assistant provost for research, development and civic engagement Taviare "Tav" Hawkins, Ph.D., has joined Wagner College as the inaugural assistant provost for research, development,
    Nicole DeStefano HeadshotHidden Image July 31, 2023 Nicole DeStefano named director of development and external relations Nicole DeStefano, currently vice president for development at the Staten Island Economic Development Corporation (SIEDC), will join Wagner College as director of development and external relations in
    RS61135 Donald Crooks 1PRHidden Image July 1, 2023 Wagner College business professor Donald L. "Donnie" Crooks retires Business professor Donald L. Crooks ’68 M’72 retired at the end of the fall 2022 semester, capping a 19-year career at Wagner College. When Crooks joined the Wagner faculty in 2003, he brought with
     
    • Wagner Magazine

      Stories from alumni around the world.

      Read the magazine

    • Contact the newsroom

      communications@wagner.edu

    • Wagner in the media

      Wagner College news coverage

      Browse Catalog

    • Visit Campus
    • Explore Majors
    • Library
    • Make a Gift
    Wagner College
    Work One Campus Road
    Staten Island, NY 10301
    • CONTACT US
    • Privacy Policy
    Back top