Skip to Content
  • facebook
  • twitter
  • instagram
  • youtube
  • flickr
  • WAGNER.EDU
  • A-Z
    A
    • Academic and Cultural Enrichment
    • Admissions
    • Alumni & Friends
    • Anthropology Department
    • Arts Administration
    • Athletics
    B
    • Biological Sciences Department
    • Bookstore
    • Business, Nicolais School
    • Business Office
    C
    • Calendar
    • Campus Life
    • Campus Services
    • Center for Academic & Career Engagement
    • Center for Intercultural Advancement
    • Center for Leadership & Community Engagement
    • Center for Spirituality
    • Children & Teens Programs
    • Commencement
    • Communications & Marketing
    • Conference Services
    • Continuing Education
    D
    • Dance Program
    • Dining Services
    • Diversity, Equity and Inclusion
    E
    • Early Childhood Center
    • Economics Department
    • Education Department
    • English Department
    • Expanding Your Horizons
    F
    • Faculty Research Sites
    • Film & Media
    • Film & Photo Shoots
    • Financial Aid
    G
    • Gender Studies
    • Government & Politics Department
    • Give to Wagner
    H
    • HawkTalk Blog
    • Health & Wellness
    • History Department
    • Holocaust Center
    • Honors Program
    • Hugh L. Carey Institute for Government Reform
    • Human Resources
    I
    • Information Technology
    • Institutional Advancement
    L
    • Library
    • Lifelong Learning Department
    M
    • Math & Computer Science
    • Modern Languages, Literatures & Cultures
    • Music Department
    N
    • Newsroom
    • New Students Hub
    • Nursing, Evelyn L. Spiro School
    P
    • Performing Arts
    • Philosophy & Religious Studies Department
    • Physical Sciences Department
    • Physician Assistant
    • Planetarium
    • Pre-Health Science Program
    • Pre-Law Program
    • President’s Office
    • Provost’s Office
    • Psychology Department
    • Public Safety
    R
    • Registrar
    • Residential Education
    S
    • Sociology Department
    • Student Engagement and Activities
    • Student Government Association
    • Study Abroad
    T
    • Theatre
    • Theatre Season
    • Title IX
    V
    • Veteran’s Resources
    • Visual Arts Department
    W
    • Wagner Fund
    • Wagner Magazine
    • WCBG Student Radio
    • Writing Center
  • QuickLinks
    ONLINE
    • Directory
    • Follett Discover Access
    • Mailport
    • Make a Gift
    • Moodle
    • myWagner
    • Wagner Works
    ON CAMPUS
    • Events Calendar
    • Job Opportunities
    • Library
    • Registrar’s Office
    • Theatre Season
    • Visit Us
    • Webcam
    MORE RESOURCES
    • For Employees
    • For Faculty
    • For Current Students
    • For New Students
    • For Community
    • For Alumni
    • For Parents
Wagner College Newsroom
  • Events
  • Stories
  • Contact
  • Newsroom MENU
    • WAGNER.EDU
    Setback for Recall Movement may be Temporary
    December 15, 2010 Share
    Share on Facebook
    Facebook
    Tweet about this on Twitter
    Twitter
    Share on LinkedIn
    Linkedin
    Pin on Pinterest
    Pinterest
    Email this to someone
    email
    Text Size


    The Record [Bergen County, N.J.]
    Tuesday, November 23, 2010
    SETBACK FOR RECALL MOVEMENT MAY BE TEMPORARY
    BY JOSHUA SPIVAK
        Supporters of the quick hook for federally elected officials were dealt a severe blow last week as the state Supreme Court ruled that Sen. Bob Menendez, as well as all other federal officials, are not subject to a recall vote.
        The decision, overturning a lower court ruling allowing the recall to go forward, agrees with other court rulings that the recall cannot be utilized at the federal level. But recall proponents are not done yet. And there could be a chance, though most likely very small, that they could survive to fight another day.
        The decision did leave some room for hope for the recall proponents. Two of the judges dissented, arguing that the recall should have been allowed to progress, as did the appellate court judges. While this doesn’t have any practical effect, it does mean that the proponents were able to convince at least two high-level judges of their argument.
        Since they have promised to appeal the decision to the U.S. Supreme Court, they have to hope to do better. The recall backers also have another case in the hopper, as recall proponents are also trying to recall North Dakota Sen. Kent Conrad, and had been threatening a recall of Louisiana’s Mary Landrieu.
        Recall backers are hoping that their side of history gets the best of a Supreme Court argument. The recall goes back to the beginning of the country – it made its first appearance in 1631 in the Massachusetts Bay Colony. A recall provision was also included in the Constitution’s predecessor document, the Articles of Confederation, though it apparently was never exercised.
        Unfortunately for the recall proponents, history takes a sharp turn for the worse once the Constitutional Convention met. The famed Virginia Plan, proposed by Gov. Edmund Randolph, would have allowed the recall of the members of the first house of the legislature, who were slated to be directly elected by the people. But the convention struck the provision out.
        The lack of a recall played a major part in the Anti-Federalist attack on the Constitution. Two major Constitution opponents, Luther Martin of Maryland and John Lansing of New York, stressed the absence of a recall for senators and the senators’ freedom from popular control as reasons to reject the Constitution.
        George Washington cited
        Recall proponents and the dissenting New Jersey judges also cite a letter of George Washington to his nephew that references a recall. However, the Anti-Federalists lost, and lost badly. The recall was not put into the Constitution, and the view of others, most notably Alexander Hamilton, carried the day. When James Madison proposed his Amendments to the Constitution, the recall was nowhere to be found.
        This wasn’t the end of the recall. In 1790, Rhode Island proposed granting the right to recall, as did Virginia in 1803 and 1808. It also came back to life in the debates surrounding the 17th Amendment, which stripped from the state legislatures the rights to elect senators and put it in the voters’ hands, though it was not included in that amendment.
        ‘Hair-trigger reform’
        At this time, William Howard Taft wrote a book denouncing the recall, which he memorably cited as the “hair-trigger form of government.”
        In addition to all this historical hurdle, in the 1995 case of United States Term Limits v. Thornton, the United States Supreme Court mentions in both the decision and the dissent that federal officials are not subject to the recall. Proponents may take some solace in the fact that four of the justices who participated in the Thornton case have since been replaced.
        If the North Dakota Supreme Court allows the Conrad recall to go forward, the U.S. Supreme Court may feel a need to clarify the constitutionality of the recall. If it doesn’t, there’s probably a good chance the court will just let the states’ high court decisions stand.
        Rarely used
        If the recall goes forward, it might be some time before we see a wave of federal recalls. The recall is only available against statewide officials in 18 states, and a number of those limit it to state officials. And in the 102-year history of the state-level recall, only two governors and about 20 or so state legislators have ever faced a recall.
        Thanks to technology and more money being used, that would probably change in a hurry if a recall were approved for federal officials. But any flood would probably take some time.
        Recall backers had a bad day last Thursday. The New Jersey court’s decision is clearly a setback in their attempt to remove federally elected officials.
        But their fight is clearly not over. We may still have to wait and see if senators are subject to the recall.
        Joshua Spivak, a public relations executive and attorney, is a senior fellow at the Hugh L. Carey Institute for Government Reform at Wagner College.
     

      • Uncategorized

    Popular Stories

    • Harry Jackson1 Harry Jackson1

      Former SGA leader Harry Jackson ’09 dies

      August 3, 2022

    • Alumni Awards ProgramLR Alumni Awards ProgramLR

      2022 Alumni Awards

      July 14, 2022

    • Tarshia Stanley1 Tarshia Stanley1

      Wagner College’s next provost is Tarshia Stanley

      November 4, 2021
     

    Related Stories

    main hall building imageHidden Image May 23, 2022 Spring 2022 pinning ceremony On Thursday, May 19, Wagner College’s Evelyn L. Spiro School of Nursing held its spring pinning ceremony in the Main Hall auditorium for those graduating with a bachelor of science in nursing degree
    Spring BreakHidden Image March 16, 2022 Spring Break 2022 What’s open, and when, during Spring Break week, March 19-27
    WinterHidden Image January 13, 2022 Winter Break campus service hours What’s open — and when — throughout the 2021-22 Winter Break
    main hall building imageHidden Image November 17, 2021 Faculty awards 2021 Congratulations to all the Wagner College faculty members whose exceptional performance and career milestones were recognized at the annual Faculty Awards Dinner on Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2021. FACULTY AWARDS
    Tarshia Stanley1Hidden Image November 4, 2021 Wagner College’s next provost is Tarshia Stanley Currently a dean at St. Catherine University in Minnesota, Stanley will take office June 1
    Autumnal sceneaHidden Image October 8, 2021 Fall Break 2021 What’s open on campus, and when, over the Fall Break weekend, Oct. 9-12
    The cast singing togetherHidden Image September 15, 2021 Wagner College Theatre lineup ‘Small Mouth Sounds’ opens Stage One season Oct. 7; Main Stage season opens with ‘Into the Woods’ Oct. 21
    main hall building imageHidden Image May 10, 2021 Current exhibition: Orly Cogan ‘Go Your Own Way’ Wagner College Union Gallery is pleased to present this selection of work from the fiber and multi-media artist Orly Cogan. Through her tapestries,
    main hall building imageHidden Image March 10, 2021 2021 Black History Month Read-Aloud On Thursday, March 4, several members of the Wagner College community participated in the 2021 Black History Month Read-Aloud, reading brief selections from the poems, novels and essays of Black writers.
     
    • Wagner Magazine

      Stories from alumni around the world.

      Read the magazine

    • Contact the newsroom

      Media relations director Lee Manchester
      lee.manchester@wagner.edu
      718-420-4504

    • Wagner in the media

      Wagner College 2019 news coverage

      Browse Catalog

    • Visit Campus
    • Explore Majors
    • Library
    • Make a Gift
    Wagner College
    Work One Campus Road
    Staten Island, NY 10301
    • CONTACT US
    • Privacy Policy
    Back top