Skip to Content
  • facebook
  • twitter
  • instagram
  • youtube
  • flickr
  • WAGNER.EDU
  • A-Z
    A
    • Academic and Cultural Enrichment
    • Admissions
    • Alumni & Friends
    • Anthropology Department
    • Arts Administration
    • Athletics
    B
    • Biological Sciences Department
    • Bookstore
    • Business, Nicolais School
    • Business Office
    C
    • Calendar
    • Campus Life
    • Campus Services
    • Center for Academic & Career Engagement
    • Center for Intercultural Advancement
    • Center for Leadership & Community Engagement
    • Center for Spirituality
    • Children & Teens Programs
    • Commencement
    • Communications & Marketing
    • Conference Services
    • Continuing Education
    D
    • Dance Program
    • Dining Services
    • Diversity, Equity and Inclusion
    E
    • Early Childhood Center
    • Economics Department
    • Education Department
    • English Department
    • Expanding Your Horizons
    F
    • Faculty Research Sites
    • Film & Media
    • Film & Photo Shoots
    • Financial Aid
    G
    • Gender Studies
    • Government & Politics Department
    • Give to Wagner
    H
    • HawkTalk Blog
    • Health & Wellness
    • History Department
    • Holocaust Center
    • Honors Program
    • Hugh L. Carey Institute for Government Reform
    • Human Resources
    I
    • Information Technology
    • Institutional Advancement
    L
    • Library
    • Lifelong Learning Department
    M
    • Math & Computer Science
    • Modern Languages, Literatures & Cultures
    • Music Department
    N
    • Newsroom
    • New Students Hub
    • Nursing, Evelyn L. Spiro School
    P
    • Performing Arts
    • Philosophy & Religious Studies Department
    • Physical Sciences Department
    • Physician Assistant
    • Planetarium
    • Pre-Health Science Program
    • Pre-Law Program
    • President’s Office
    • Provost’s Office
    • Psychology Department
    • Public Safety
    R
    • Registrar
    • Residential Education
    S
    • Sociology Department
    • Student Engagement and Activities
    • Student Government Association
    • Study Abroad
    T
    • Theatre
    • Theatre Season
    • Title IX
    V
    • Veteran’s Resources
    • Visual Arts Department
    W
    • Wagner Fund
    • Wagner Magazine
    • WCBG Student Radio
    • Writing Center
  • QuickLinks
    ONLINE
    • Directory
    • Follett Discover Access
    • Mailport
    • Make a Gift
    • Moodle
    • myWagner
    • Wagner Works
    ON CAMPUS
    • Events Calendar
    • Job Opportunities
    • Library
    • Registrar’s Office
    • Theatre Season
    • Visit Us
    • Webcam
    MORE RESOURCES
    • For Employees
    • For Faculty
    • For Current Students
    • For New Students
    • For Community
    • For Alumni
    • For Parents
Wagner College Newsroom
  • Events
  • Stories
  • Contact
  • Newsroom MENU
    • WAGNER.EDU
    Trend Toward Recall Efforts on the Rise for Cities, States
    December 15, 2010 Share
    Share on Facebook
    Facebook
    Tweet about this on Twitter
    Twitter
    Share on LinkedIn
    Linkedin
    Pin on Pinterest
    Pinterest
    Email this to someone
    email
    Text Size


    Wednesday, December 1, 2010
    TREND TOWARD RECALL EFFORTS ON THE RISE FOR CITIES, STATES
    By JOSHUA SPIVAK
        While a potential recall election for Mayor Jim Suttle would engender much debate, it could give Omaha a new distinction — it would be the largest city in America to recall and remove two mayors. It also may be on the cutting edge of a new trend. Recalls have exploded in growth in recent years. The reason for this growth also should concern Suttle’s supporters — recalls are frequently successful.
        Omaha is no stranger to this fact, as many voters recall the 1987 ouster of Mayor Mike Boyle. In the ensuing 24 years, the recall has become more popular than ever.
        Most people are familiar with the circus-like atmosphere surrounding the recall of California Gov. Gray Davis, only the second governor in the country to face a recall vote. However, there have been plenty of others.
        For example, before 1994, California had not gotten a recall on the ballot against a state legislator in 79 years. Since then, there have been five. And just this year, Miami looks set to vote on recalling its mayor in January.
        What explains this resurgence? One is that emerging communications technology has made running a signature-gathering campaign easier than ever. As we’ve seen with initiatives, it is significantly easier to organize and run the signature-gathering efforts that are needed to get a recall on the ballot. And since the Internet has become ubiquitous, rumor campaigns and directed e-mails have become a potent tool.
        The simple math of lower voter turnout also has helped recalls become more likely. In general, with a few blips, voter turnout has dropped precipitously over the past several decades.
        The number of signatures it takes to qualify a recall for the ballot is directly tied to the number of voters who participated in the previous election. So a decrease in turnout means it takes a smaller portion of signatures from the overall electorate to qualify a recall.
        For local elections, this could be particularly easy. For example, Miami requires only 4 percent of total registered voters to sign this petition. In Omaha, you need 20 percent of the turnout for the most recent mayoral election, which is not going to be a high number. In Akron, Ohio, where the mayor beat back a recall last year, the recall proponents needed only a few thousand signatures.
        The other explanation for the resurgence is that recalls frequently work. There is no nationwide study on their effectiveness, but they frequently succeed in knocking off incumbents. There have been 20 or so recall elections for state legislators in the country’s history. In 13 of those, the official was recalled.
        The reason for this result is that recall votes are generally stand-alone special elections. Voters have to both be aware of the recall vote and care enough to come out to cast a ballot for one race. Not surprisingly, voters who come out to cast their ballots are often the most highly motivated, which certainly defines people who are intent on removing an elected official.
        When recalls take place on a non-special-election basis, i.e., the same day as a regularly scheduled vote, candidates seem to have a better chance of survival. The two most recent state legislative recalls — one in California, the other in Michigan, both of which took place in 2008 — illustrate this point. Both were scheduled for the same day as a primary, and both candidates survived.
        None of this means that Suttle is doomed. While recall proponents have latched on to a popular issue for recalls — taxes — it is not always successful. The best recall issue is one that rides on a feeling of betrayal. Whether it is because of a corruption scandal or a switched vote — as in the case of a Wisconsin state senator who was booted out for switching his vote to support a tax to build a baseball stadium — betrayal is the most powerful argument for a recall.
        At least Suttle can take some comfort in a few other historical facts. Being the subject of a recall doesn’t end a career — it could be a good jumping-off point. California Sen. Dianne Feinstein survived a recall when she was mayor of San Francisco, as did Congressman Dennis Kuchinch when he was mayor of Cleveland.
        Even losing a recall doesn’t mean it’s the end. North Dakota’s Lynn Frazier, the first governor ever to be recalled in 1921, went on to win three terms in the U.S. Senate.
        The writer, of Staten Island, N.Y., is a senior fellow at the Hugh L. Carey Institute for Government Reform at Wagner College. He is the founder of the website RecallElections.com.
     

      • Uncategorized

    Popular Stories

    • Harry Jackson1 Harry Jackson1

      Former SGA leader Harry Jackson ’09 dies

      August 3, 2022

    • Alumni Awards ProgramLR Alumni Awards ProgramLR

      2022 Alumni Awards

      July 14, 2022

    • Tarshia Stanley1 Tarshia Stanley1

      Wagner College’s next provost is Tarshia Stanley

      November 4, 2021
     

    Related Stories

    main hall building imageHidden Image May 23, 2022 Spring 2022 pinning ceremony On Thursday, May 19, Wagner College’s Evelyn L. Spiro School of Nursing held its spring pinning ceremony in the Main Hall auditorium for those graduating with a bachelor of science in nursing degree
    Spring BreakHidden Image March 16, 2022 Spring Break 2022 What’s open, and when, during Spring Break week, March 19-27
    WinterHidden Image January 13, 2022 Winter Break campus service hours What’s open — and when — throughout the 2021-22 Winter Break
    main hall building imageHidden Image November 17, 2021 Faculty awards 2021 Congratulations to all the Wagner College faculty members whose exceptional performance and career milestones were recognized at the annual Faculty Awards Dinner on Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2021. FACULTY AWARDS
    Tarshia Stanley1Hidden Image November 4, 2021 Wagner College’s next provost is Tarshia Stanley Currently a dean at St. Catherine University in Minnesota, Stanley will take office June 1
    Autumnal sceneaHidden Image October 8, 2021 Fall Break 2021 What’s open on campus, and when, over the Fall Break weekend, Oct. 9-12
    The cast singing togetherHidden Image September 15, 2021 Wagner College Theatre lineup ‘Small Mouth Sounds’ opens Stage One season Oct. 7; Main Stage season opens with ‘Into the Woods’ Oct. 21
    main hall building imageHidden Image May 10, 2021 Current exhibition: Orly Cogan ‘Go Your Own Way’ Wagner College Union Gallery is pleased to present this selection of work from the fiber and multi-media artist Orly Cogan. Through her tapestries,
    main hall building imageHidden Image March 10, 2021 2021 Black History Month Read-Aloud On Thursday, March 4, several members of the Wagner College community participated in the 2021 Black History Month Read-Aloud, reading brief selections from the poems, novels and essays of Black writers.
     
    • Wagner Magazine

      Stories from alumni around the world.

      Read the magazine

    • Contact the newsroom

      Media relations director Lee Manchester
      lee.manchester@wagner.edu
      718-420-4504

    • Wagner in the media

      Wagner College 2019 news coverage

      Browse Catalog

    • Visit Campus
    • Explore Majors
    • Library
    • Make a Gift
    Wagner College
    Work One Campus Road
    Staten Island, NY 10301
    • CONTACT US
    • Privacy Policy
    Back top